Stun guns: Taser debate focuses on safety in schools
by David Nivens
8 months ago | 692 views | 1 1 comments | 8 8 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Panelilsts (from left) Ian Mance (ACLU), High Point Police Chief Jim Fealy and Guilford County Sheriff BJ Barnes attend discussion at the YWCA of High Point Thursday. Don Davis Jr. | HPE
Panelilsts (from left) Ian Mance (ACLU), High Point Police Chief Jim Fealy and Guilford County Sheriff BJ Barnes attend discussion at the YWCA of High Point Thursday. Don Davis Jr. | HPE
slideshow
HIGH POINT – Stun guns are safe when properly used in dangerous circumstances, two law enforcement agency leaders said Thursday.

Guilford County Sheriff BJ Barnes and High Point Police Chief Jim Fealy told a gathering at the YWCA of High Point that officers using the weapons have a safer way to defuse violent situations. The two agencies provide Taser-armed school resource officers for many Guilford County school district high schools and middle schools.

Barnes said he believes stun guns are safer than pepper spray. Stun guns disrupt the nervous system and cause muscles to contract. The 5-second, 50,000-volt shock causes a stunned person to “freeze up.”

“Pepper spray has been attributed to more deaths,” Barnes said. “The spray lasts about 45 minutes and the Taser shock about 5 seconds. We need this stopgap. We do not want to use the .45-caliber handgun. It leaves a mark.”

Fealy and Barnes appeared with American Civil Liberties Union representative Ian Mance at a “Front Porch Conversations” session sponsored by the High Point Human Relations Commission and the YWCA.

“Most of the Taser use you see on television is a misuse, and I agree,” Fealy said. “A Taser can be a lifesaver to protect children. It is the safest weapon officers carry. We have reduced injuries since we have used them, and that is a positive thing.”

The Guilford County Board of Education has invited the same two agency leaders to discuss stun guns. Following a September incident at Ragsdale High School, several outraged parents complained to the school board about stun-gun dangers. An officer used a Taser on a 15-year-old female student after she threatened two faculty members and assaulted the officer, according to the sheriff’s office.

“Schools are much more violent now,” Barnes said.

Critics see several dangers and want stricter use policies.

“The devices have become glorified, and there is no law governing their use, just agency policies,” Mance said. “When used appropriately, like in High Point, you can limit injuries.”

Barnes and Fealy said their policies limit use of the weapons to repel attacks.

School board member Carlvena Foster, who believes officers should not use Tasers in the schools, again called for more discussions.

“The No. 1 goal is school safety,” Foster said. “We don’t have the activity in our schools that requires the use of Tasers. What works on the streets does not work at school.”

dnivens@hpe.com | 888-3626
comments (1)
« attorneywatchdog wrote on Sunday, Nov 22 at 04:10 PM »
Sheriff Barnes was a former student of Ragsdale, and knows personally, student behavior has changed in the schools since he attended classes. I am also a graduate of Ragsdale, and would like to suggest, any school board member who believes, "We don’t have the activity in our schools that requires the use of Tasers," spend no less than a week sitting in classes and walking the halls of this school in question before contributing to any further discussions. On or about 1991, a little girl 14 was stabbed, repeatedly, by her former boyfriend in front of her classmates while attending the Trinity Middle School. There were no school officers during thoses years, and believe, this incident would have been avoided by the presence of an officer in the halls. This little girl, a close friend of my own daughter and neighbor, had been provided an administrative office to complete her class assignments for a few days following an incident with her boyfriend, not a student of the school. This young man was only 16 years old when he entered a classroom, she was returned to by the administrative staff, without notifying her parents, believing there was no longer a threat to her safety. This young girl died, trying to stop the bleeding from wounds that had punctured her heart. Yes, I have personal knowledge of the change in student behavior, and know it has only gotten worse since the late 70's when I was in the classrooms as a substitute teacher. It is now thirty years later, and we have officers in the schools, but the students, who do not want to be there, are making it known louder and clearer than ever. Ms. Foster stated, "What works on the streets does not work at school." Why? Is it because Ms. Foster, you don't believe the same children in the schools are acting out the same in the streets as they are in their own homes? Not every child that attends school is subject to a taser, but every child who does attend school, required by the state, deserves to be protected from those students who do not want to be there.